(1, 2, 3, 4) 

I should have known 
With a boy like you 
Your middle name is 'Always'
I'd always love you 
Ahhh, yeah 

You let the needle drop 
I think that you 
Could do so much better 
Those conventions are 
Taking their toll on you 

A phantom is disguised 
It's horrifying 
Right before your eyes 
Phantom is inside 

I should have known 
With a boy like you 
Your middle name is 'Always'
I'd always want you 
Ahhh, yeah 

A phantom is disguised 
It's horrifying 
Right before your eyes 
The phantom is inside 
It's hideous 
Right before your eyes 
The phantom is watching you 
The phantom is watching you, you